The second rule is wrong... I have:
2) Shipping & Handling per item : Trigger = SubTotal of StandardQty > 1 : Calculation = Based on column subtotal StandardQty times 1
it should be:
2) Shipping & Handling per item : Trigger = SubTotal of StandardQty > 0 : Calculation = Based on column subtotal StandardQty times 1
OK I think I see what you are saying... so if they have both an elite and a standard item, they just pay the additional dollar for the standard? What if they have two elite?
Try this updated cart attached.