You could do this with a single page rather than two different pages. The idea is that you have a rule for the login, then you have one rule for each of the two types of users.
The page would start out with a logged in user rule applied to the page. If you do this both on the same page then you just need to have show regions for the different users. You would create both displays then use the show region server behavior to make each area only visible to the appropriate users. For example if you had rules for logged in, user type1, and user type2 then the page might be organized like this:
if not logged
send the user to the login page
if user is type 1
show the type 1 information
if the user is type 2
show the type 2 information
So the page would start with an access restriction rule for logged in so that only logged in users can access the page. Next on the page you have your listings for both types of users. Then for the first listing you would select area of the page and apply the show region server behavior, select your rule for the type 1 users. You would then do this same thing for the second display that you have on the page but you would apply the rule for the type 2 user.
You should take a look at the help documentation for Access control > Show region server behavior. There is also a solution recipe on using the show region on the support page under Solution Recipes: