The only reason this page should change depending on how you get to it would be if you were filtering any of the recordsets on the page with any query string or other variables from a form post or something like that. If the data on the page is the same then the page should behave the same regardless of how you navigate to it. Please do some testing with this page and redirecting or linking to it to see if you can narrow down when this issue occurs. If it only happens under a curtain sequence then that would point to the data on the page changing as the source of the issue. Also do you have a link where this can be seen in some fashion?