Well, I get sent a new password by email. So that is working.
When I use the password, it does not work. Neither does the old one though. So I'm thinking it is being updated in the database.
I looked at an old support ticket from when I first started using SA and I saw where I had made the characters in the db table for encrypted passwords too short (varchar(8) changed to varchar(50) per support instructions).
So I checked that and, just as I thought, I copy those db table specifications from website to website so that I don't come across that issue again.
So if it's being updated in the database and sent to me by email, could the issue be with the login page? I didn't have a problem with that until I started testing the EmailPW page.