I see... You are using an outdated checkout setting since you have an older site. It could easily be updated to use the new system and work moving forward, but I wouldn't be able to import the old orders at this point without access to your paypal account to get the order details. Can you post your phone number in the private area? I'll give you a call and discuss with you what the options are. We can of course just take down the site, but we can also correct the problem if you wanted to. We can talk about that over the phone and make sure we make the appropriate response based on your needs..