It looks like this time you ran the wizard without an encrypted password. That creates an entirely different forgot password page because the password can be emailed directly. I went to the page and filled it out and got the login information sent to me without issue. It must be in your spam folder. Try using a from address that ends with @statecollegedev.com.
You can also debug spam filter issues by using an online spam score service like: https://www.mail-tester.com/