I see the problem, in the shipping rules, you are using:
Cart Subtotal plus 9.95
Cart Subtotal plus 11.95
for the calculations, the calculations in the shipping rules should be flat rate calculations without adding the cart subtotal
Your friends over here at WebAssist! These Dreamweaver extensions will assist you in building unlimited, custom websites.
These out-of-the-box solutions provide you proven, tested applications that can be up and running now. Build a store, a gallery, or a web-based email solution.