First I tried what Mike said to do (error reporting).
Added error_reporting = 0 in php.ini file, that didn't work.
Added display_reporting = 0 in php.ini file, that didn't work.
So I decided to go back and try Jason's suggestions to change the programs.
I changed all lines suggested except the email server that was listed in php.ini as relay-hosting.secureserver.net (which is what we were given so I used that in WA Globals file)
Now I get this:
* Please provide your email addess so we can get back in touch with you.
On the good email address that has been working fine. Never let's me get pass the Captcha.