Thanks for the help, I am slowly making progress. In doing what you said, the director page worked fine (redirected to it after log in), but when I created the "Other" page, it also redirected to the director page. I realized that I listed director.php as the redirect page for the access rules, so when I deleted it and checked the "redirect to previous url if it exists" box I am back the everytime I login I get the login screen again.
Not sure why it isn't redirecting back to the director.php or other.php pages when they are logged into.
Please let me know what I am doing wrong.